Sign In  |  Register  |  About Mill Valley  |  Contact Us

Mill Valley, CA
September 01, 2020 1:29pm
7-Day Forecast | Traffic
  • Search Hotels in Mill Valley

  • CHECK-IN:
  • CHECK-OUT:
  • ROOMS:

Starbucks Buyback Plan Highlights Why Opportunistic Corporate Buying Is Rare

There are a lot of mixed feelings about corporate stock buybacks depending on which group of stakeholders one polls, but one thing is clear; finding instances when management teams choose to buy mostly when their stocks are temporarily and unfairly depressed is a difficult task. When times are good (and share prices reflect this sentiment), buybacks seem like an easy capital allocation decision for ever-optimistic CEOs and CFOs. When the tide turns cash is conserved and debt repayment takes precedent even as the stock price tanks to attractive levels. Coffee giant Starbucks (SBUX) is the latest example. With union pressure coming at them in full force, the company suspended buybacks in early April so they could improve operations and employee morale without taking a political hit from returning more cash to shareholders. This week they announced they will resume buybacks in about a year, after their turnaround plan is largely completed. You can probably guess what happened to the stock price during the last five months: See that wonderful chance for the company to retire shares in the 70’s while sentiment about their relations with employees was at its absolute worst? Yeah, sorry everyone, buybacks were suspended. Yikes. So if we can’t rely on management to repurchase shares at the best prices, should we swear off the notion that buybacks are shareholder-friendly? A lot of people take that view, but I don’t think it’s entirely fair. Buybacks remain a way to return capital to investors in a tax-efficient manner. Dividend payments force investors to sell a portion of their investment and often results in a tax liability. If you own stock it is safe to assume you want to keep it so forcing a partial sale every three months is not ideal. If you want to sell some, you can do so on your own, and in today’s world for zero commission. As an investor, it is probably best to think of stock buybacks as equivalent to a tax-free dividend reinvestment program. Your capital stays invested and taxes are avoided, which leaves you and you alone to determine the timing and magnitude of any position trimming. The dividend analogy also rings true because just as dividend payments are executed every quarter no matter the price of the stock, so too are most buyback programs (unfortunately). All in all, buybacks are probably here to stay even with the new 1% federal tax that begins next year. While I prefer them to dividends (for growth companies especially), it is still pretty annoying when companies don’t match their buyback patterns with the underlying stock price volatility. When a cash cow business like Starbucks adopts the same shortcomings, it’s a good reminder that they are the rule more than the exception. Full Disclosure: Long shares of SBUX at the time of writing but positions may change at any time
Data & News supplied by www.cloudquote.io
Stock quotes supplied by Barchart
Quotes delayed at least 20 minutes.
By accessing this page, you agree to the following
Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions.
 
 
Copyright © 2010-2020 MillValley.com & California Media Partners, LLC. All rights reserved.